COD Scam: What is going on here? What to do? Help!
Summary: A participant, identified as tryubik-useonlyasdirected, faced an unexpected charge of $24+ on a package shipped from the USA to Canada, citing COD for shipping. They sought advice on whether paying would allow for a refund via eBay, or if refusing the package would result in a loss. lotzofuniquegoodies and devon@ebay suggested reporting the issue to eBay and contacting them for potential refunds. femmefan1946 advised that refusing the package would let the seller keep it and the money. Later discussions revealed it was a customs charge misidentified as shipping—Canadian law exempts books from certain taxes, meaning the charge shouldn't have applied. After clarification, tryubik-useonlyasdirected paid the charge, resolved the issue with the seller, who offered to help with customs fees, and plans to claim a rebate. Several participants contributed insights, revealing complexities in international shipping and taxing processes.
Our package arrived today and when we went to pick up the item Canada Post said we owe $24+ towards a COD charge! We've asked them to hold the item.
Does anyone have experience with this? CPC said the COD is for shipping (not duty, not import, not brokerage). Our book cost nearly $100 plus $8+ shipping (also in retrospect, about the cost of a COD!...). The purchase was from the USA into Canada and our end of the shipping costs have already been paid.
If there is any shipping overage it is the sellers responsibility. The seller has been contacted but most of their feedback indicates they won't respond so we're trying to figure out the best course of action.
What should we do?
- If we pay the COD, can we get the difference back from eBay? Postage is the sellers responsibility.
- If we refuse acceptance will we get our money back? The seller has a no returns policy.
Additionaly there are a substantial number of folks in the sellers feedback who claim the item recieved wasn't the item ordered. Now, we haven't opened the package but given that the shipping is already a scam we're concerned that if we accepted the COD the book might not even be the correct one purchased. If it isn't the right book, will we still get our money back if they have a no returns/no refunds policy? Or will they say we can't open another claim because we've already opened a claim on the COD?
What is going on here? What to do? Help!
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OP@fergua3It would certainly help if in the shipping options sellers were required to say whether they ship USPS/CPC etc or Private Courier/Intermediary/eBay Global. A buyer should know ahead of time what charges to expect. Is it law that this has to be disclosed? Actually, I'm kind of curious now. I know at ConceptTwo and B and H Photo etc.. they say how the item will be shipped and what fees to expect, because both use private.
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OP@fergua3There is no accompanying customs documentation at all, certainly nothing like when you take it to customs directly. There is only a breakdown at the bottom of the label that says a COD charge for Duty: 0.00 Tax: $17.xx Fee: $7.xx
And exactly as @femmefan1946 says - it is the shippers responsibility to know the law of the Country they are shipping too and collect all appropriate information regarding the documentation from the seller at the time of purchase of the label and process, or not, accordingly. The seller utilizes their service because it is their business. It is their responsiility to know that a book is not taxable because - repeatedly charging tax on a non-taxable item quickly appears like tax fraud!
This is a known issue with intermediary shipping companies. Just last year I purchased an item from a major US business and prepaid the tax and duty at point of sale. The UPS tried to double charge the tax and when I called them out on it they refused to release my package. I had to tell them to send it back, that I would be in contact with the major retailer about their service, and also with the appropriate government reporting agency. They still refused to release the item. About 5 minutes after I hung up the phone they called back and said the item was released and on its way! It was not the first time it had happened to me and others have told me the same. They knew the tax and duty were paid because they didn't ask for proof. These are serious issues. If they dont adequatley train their employees then they shouldn't be employed or in the business in the first place. *rant over*
fergua3
Very interesting. This is one of the many reasons i hate dealing with courier companies and will never buy from someone who ships by courier. Courier companies are borderline organized crime as far as i'm concerned.
If Ebay truly cared about giving a good buying experience, then they would come out with an international shipping program that uses the postal system, so there would be no nasty surprise brokerage fees, taxes charged when they shouldn't be, waiting around all day for your package to be delivered, no shows by delivery drivers, delivery drivers that just stick a notice on your door instead of actually trying to deliver, items marked as delivered that never were etc etc etc.
fergua3
of course i just realized in your case it wasn't a courier company, was it. They were an intermediary. Same rant applies though i guess. They should be leaving it up to the CRA to collect appropriate customs fees and taxes, especially since they can't do it correctly.
marnotom!
The book may have been "pre-cleared" for customs by ePost Global or (more likely) a logistics outfit contracted by ePost Global and CBSA may have just electronically rubber-stamped it.
Does the customs documention look all offical and CBSA-ish? You mentioned something about the label looking different.
fergua3
so it was a Customs tax afterall. The fee must have been small. I assume the value of the book was $100USD. So HST on that would be about $18, so the fee must have only been about $7? If the fee was 9.95 then it is the standard CRA fee when processing inbound items. Too bad you were charged at all, but that is just one of the problems with these international shipping programs, they don't know all the details of the import laws of each country.
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OPAlright folks settle down, here's the scoop: turns out the Ruckus is on me (and the postal agent who didn't specify beyond shipping because there was a long line-up). The postal agent was very helpful today, the charge was broken down on the label: Tax +**bleep**-Service-Fee charged by the intermediary shipper. If I'd known this yesterday it would have been paid. Though, the ruckus is also on the shipper/customs because they knew it is a book and there is no full HST on books in Ontario!
The "COD" which is actually "Customs" is paid for, the package brought home, the book oogled, and the seller beefed for only shipping it in a brown-card-bag. (To be fair the seller actually got in touch with us and offered to pay the customs because they didn't let us know about it ahead of time!)
This thread also shows why it is best to be prepaired because I know there is no HST on books and had no idea how to rectify this at the counter, or if you even can when multiple shippers have been involved.
@marnotom!Thank you for that link to the Point-of-Sale Rebate on Books. Do you have any experience with how to go about the process if you've already paid the amount? Will I be required to fill out the CRA rebate claim Form GST 189? Its a bit confusing as the page states that the CBSA should have automatically deducted the amount for internet imports but they did not. *sigh* If it's not one thing, it's another.
flipistics
I've never had to do it, but I think you just fill out whatever form it is along with the receipt (you can download the tax receipt from your purchase history). Keep in mind that not ALL books qualify though.
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OPIt should, its Art Reference. Unforunately the link on the government website doesn't work, figures. (https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/forms-publications/forms/gst189.html)
Customs shouldn't have processed it in the first place:
marnotom!
https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/forms-publications/publications/gi-065/point-sale-rebate-on-books.html
fergua3
that's true, you'd think that would apply when Customs assesses taxes on books as well. So perhaps the COD amount is just coincidental then. I hope OP returns to tell us what happened. Maybe this is a nasty new surprise awaiting some who buy using EIS.
marnotom!
eIS wasn't used to facilitate this shipment, though.
marnotom!
I still don't understand this, @tryubik-useonlyasdirected . USPS doesn't do international COD shipments, UPS doesn't, and I'm sure most other major carriers won't do this unless both parties have special accounts, so I don't know why ePost Global would. I'm wondering if the clerk misspoke themselves. I've had Canada Post pickup cards with "COD" scrawled on them and it turned out to be taxes and customs charges that I had to pay.
I've found Parcelsapp.com to be a very good at providing fairly detailed information on international shipments involving multiple carriers. Check your tracking there and see if there's more information than what Canada Post and eBay are providing.
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OP@marnotom!We will for certain be triple checking to make sure that it isn't some sort of tax again before creating any sort of ruckus. 🙂 The attendant did state twice as we rechecked it at the counter that it was an amount owing on the cost of shipping for this size of package. TBH the label looked different than they usually do as well but we didn't inspect it too closely ourselves before asking them to hold.
Anyhow I'll update here as the process plays out that way other folks may be offered some guidance or heads up in the future.
We'll be heading back first thing tomorrow and playing it by ear. Being sellers ourself we always try to do our due diligence before embarking farther into the eBay system. Maybe devon@ebay 's suggestion won't be required, but if it is that will be whats followed. Thank you Devon for your reply and direction in this matter.
fergua3
don't know if OP stated where they live, but, if they live in the Atlantic Provinces then this may well be a charge by Canada Customs, not a COD postage due charge. The book was $100. 15% tax (which is HST in the Altantic Provinces) plus 9.95 fee is almost $25. I'd be surprised if OP didn't get charged by Canada Customs for tax, given the value of the book. Christmas time you might be able to get an item thru Customs without being charged tax but not usually at this time of year.
reallynicestamps
@fergua3 charged by Canada Customs for tax, given the value of the book.
But we have a $150 duty free allowance on imports from the USA under CUSMA/NAFTA (and a $40 tax free allowance) so I don't think duty should be charged.
fergua3
i said twice i was talking about tax, not duties. Tax. The book was $100. Whether that's in CAD or USD i'd be surprised if tax wasn't charged by Customs.
Marnotom!, the tax payable varies by province. In provinces without HST then yup, it's just 5% GST. But in Ontario, for example, the tax payable is the amount of HST which is 13%, In the Atlantic Provinces the tax payable is the HST which there is 15%. It's different depending on what province the buyer lives in.
So, as i said, IF the buyer lives in one of the Atlantic provinces, then the tax would be about $15, if the OP's quote of book's value is in CAD. Plus Customs charges of $9.95 on top, the total would be $24.95, which is in line with the OP's stating that the COD amount owed was $24+.
Could be a coincidence and i don't know where the OP lives, but it's my hunch that the COD amount is actually a Customs amount being reimbursed . Hopefully OP will return and fill us in.
femmefan1946
if they live in the Atlantic Provinces then this may well be a charge by Canada Customs, not a COD postage due charge....
i said twice i was talking about tax, not duties. Tax.
I was confused by the mention of Customs, since the first job of Customs is collecting duties, and taxes are secondary.
Too bad you were charged at all, but that is just one of the problems with these international shipping programs, they don't know all the details of the import laws of each country.
Except that is their job.
It's what the "customs brokerage fee" is for.
marnotom!
Ah, that little bit of additional information is making things make more sense now.
The seller likely did somehow underpay ePost Global for shipping the item to Canada, but how they would have done that and whether or not it was an honest slip-up is are mysteries. You said the label looked "different." I wonder if there's any customs information on it?
fergua3
well then maybe Eglobal paid the Customs fee (HST plus 9.95 fee) and this is how they recover it. So, to the postal attendant it would look like a COD charge because it's from the shipper. I still think the root charge is from Canada Customs...the amount is too coincidental.
marnotom!
Maybe, but if the book is US$100, that would convert to about C$136 at current exchange rates. 5% GST on that would be C$6.80, making all the customs handling charges about C$18.00. There might charges other than the usual C$9.95 for a postal import if the item was handled by an entity other than CBSA, I suppose.
(If the $100 quoted by @tryubik-useonlyasdirected is Canadian dollars, then the amount for GST would be C$5.00 and the customs stuff about $19.00.)
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OP@marnotom!Standard International Shipping, Located in Ohio. The tracking number shows it went through ePost Global before being handed onto CPC. The package is fairly large 13" x 10" x 3" and heavy. From our experience in shipping $24+ feels about right using the cheapest method TBH.
If we pay the COD receipt under protest and get a written statement saying the COD is a shipping shortage only, would eBay recover the cost? It seems the buyer should have to refund the amount owed for the COD.
I get it if its taxes or import, I purchased a $1200 purchase at christmas and promptly paid the $200+ extra bits. This would be the buyers responsibility, it is just so clearly the sellers responsibility for the shipping cost. 😕
marnotom!
This is really weird. Why would Canada Post be concerned about a shortage in postage for a parcel that originated from the United States? My experience with letters from the US marked "postage due" is that Canada Post just ignores the marking. Maybe it's different for parcels and Canada Post wants its share?
What is the shipping method as stated on the listing page, @tryubik-useonlyasdirected ? There's something that doesn't quite add up here for me.
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OPeBay needs to up their game along side the scammers here because being held hostage for (a now) $175 book or $150 for no book isn't exactly a "shop with us" policy. I see we should have went with abebooks. Thanx @femmefan1946
Would it be covered under this policy? It is the only other reference on these forums I could find to a similar incident, it is the sellers responsibility to pay the postage ... would eBay honor it in this situation?
I'll try and get in touch with eBay I guess, do they have a chat somewhere?
fergua3
seems like this situation is already covered under Ebay's MBG policy. I don't know if proof is required by Ebay (i doubt it), but it would be a good idea to get something in writing from the Post Office stating that there were COD charges on this package for postage due (as opposed to Customs fees due).
femmefan1946
If you refuse the package it would be Undeliverable -- and the sketchey seller would eventually get back whatever he sent and would not be required to refund you a penny.
If you pay for the COD , neither eBay nor the sketchey seller is going to refund you that payment.
And you may have a book that cost you $132.
Since @devon@ebay has already been notified I'd also contact the eBay social media chats
https://www.facebook.com/eBayForBusiness/ — Message button in upper right on landing page.
and ask for advice.
lotzofuniquegoodies
@devon@ebay
Do you have suggestions for how this buyer should proceed and what protections they will have?
-Lotz
devon@ebay
Hi @lotzofuniquegoodies! I apologize about the situation @tryubik-useonlyasdirected is going through. What can be done is that a return case can be opened to have the seller refund OP the portion that they had to pay for the remainder of the shipping. Also I recommend to report the seller so that way the correct team can look into the account to see if this something that is being done to other buyers from that particular seller.
tryubik-useonlyasdirected
OPThanks for the devon shout out @lotzofuniquegoodies !