Why I no longer buy eIS items from US
Summary: In a discussion about purchasing items through eBay, theoldestfart expressed frustration about the high additional costs incurred when buying from US sellers, citing shipping fees and import taxes as deterrents. marnotom! questioned the assumption of fees, suggesting a possibility of tax exemption under certain conditions. There was a consensus among participants that it is often more economical to buy locally, with brettjet38 and electricalley affirming that Western governments are encouraging local buying. electricalley highlighted grievances with eBay's International Shipping program (eIS), describing additional costs and logistical challenges that deter Canadian buyers. Technical details and complaints included standardized shipping rates that seem to favor sellers, delays due to eBay's international shipping hub, and difficulties in combining shipping costs. Throughout the discussion, there were various suggestions and clarifications about the shipping processes used by eBay and potential alternatives for more cost-effective shopping.
This is a prime example of why I am sticking to what little purchasing I do these days on eBay to Canadian sellers. I was watching an item in San Antonio Tx. The seller put out an offer for $20 USD for the item that was listed for $28 USD. I turned down the offer. The reason was that by the time the item crossed the US border the $27 shipping charge would mean the item was $63 CDN plus the $10 brokerage fee via Canada Post plus the 12% PST & GST charged on it. It is no longer cost-effective to buy from US sellers.
leaky-bucket-labs
what brokerage? we pay that when we buy the item. we pay tax and "duties"
marnotom!
Some components of eIS have changed or evolved in the six and a half months since this thread was started.
reallynicestamps
You are right about the shipping charge raising the cost of the item from $20 to $47.
And that the service fee/customs brokerage fee from Canada Post is $9.95.
However, you would only be paying import fees on the $20USD/$25Cdn selling price- and we have a $150 duty free and $40 tax free exemption on imports from the USA.
This change happened in 2020 with the MUSCA (new NAFTA) agreement.
On your specific purchase there should be no import fees and no service fee.
marnotom!
That's certainly true for items sent by courier. The old tax and duty-free exemption of C$20 is still officially in place for items sent by mail, however.
reallynicestamps
First Class International Package does include tracking to Canada.
https://www.stamps.com/usps/international-package-tracking/
"FCPIS tracking available only to: Australia, Belgium, Canada, Croatia, Estonia, Finland, Germany, Great Britain and Northern Ireland, Hungary, Israel, Latvia, Lithuania, Malaysia, Malta, Netherlands, New Zealand, Singapore, Spain, and Switzerland."
lotzofuniquegoodies
Clarification. My search results inadvertently brought up First Class Mail Intl which does not have tracking. That service is not even included in eBays list. Correct service from the calculator should have been USPS First Class Package International. I was pretty sure it did include tracking. According to USPS that service quotes 2 to 8 business days. The names are very similar.
reallynicestamps
They are similar.
And two to eight business days is optimistic in my opinion.
marnotom!
First Class Mail International would be what Canada Post would call Letter-post - International or Letter-post - USA. None of these is "postal legal" for sending merchandise. If Letter-post is still an option on eBay Canada, it should be removed as well. Lettermail is a domestic service and is acceptable for merchandise. Thanks again for clearing up that distinction a few moons ago, @pjcdn20052!
theoldestfart
OPThe last thing I bought on eBay was a year ago and it was an item from someone in Canada. I have bought thousands of dollars of stuff from China directly. It is not unusual to get items from China in 9 days to 2 weeks. The last eBay item from a US seller probably was 2+ years ago.
With eBay.ca and auction items, I have to constantly add current item price + shipping and take a guess at what total Import taxes will be (12% sales taxes + ?). I have to do this with every auction item to determine whether the item is worth it at the current bid price. eBay.ca it seems is incapable of displaying that in the door price in the item listing. They know where I live I am signed into my eBay account.
lotzofuniquegoodies
@theoldestfart
According to google and the eBay Calculator Tool for US sellers the cheapest method to ship to Canada is USPS First Class Standard. US sellers if they use eBay labels would have access to a small discount.
With rates starting at $14.11, First Class Package International Service® is the lowest cost option among all shipping carriers for packages weighing up to 4 pounds. Package delivery takes between 11 to 20 business days, and the low shipping rate makes this service an ideal option for products priced under $50.
On another part of the page it mentions 2 to 8 days but that seems overly optimistic. Unfortunately it does not include tracking and is why many of those "paranoid" US type sellers are afraid to use. According to the eBay tool delivery time is a nice round 0 days. There is an announcement on dot com that USPS rates are going up this month (July) which will not help but still better for anyone okay with no tracking and quicker service than eIS can provide. (The announcements seems to skip Intl Standard to Canada but it does display using the tool. )Then it would be the do you/don't you pay tax on delivery scenario with CP but atleast a buyer would have a better idea that their purchase will not walk away.
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Announcements/July-2024-USPS-Rate-Changes/ba-p/34538677
-Lotz
lotzofuniquegoodies
A couple of videos on how eIS is supposed to work. eBay's perspective.
https://www.ebay.com/sellercenter/shipping/ebay-international-shipping
pjcdn2005
First class international package does include tracking to many countries, including Canada. The label does have to be purchased online,(including on eBay) not at the post office. Here is a list of countries that the service has tracking for.
https://faq.usps.com/s/article/Electronic-USPS-Delivery-Confirmation-International
There is also a service callled First Class International that is just for small packages similar to our international letterpost. It does not have tracking and is not supposed to be used for goods.
electricalley
I'm totally in agreement with you. eBay will soon see Canadian buyers leaving ebay.com in droves and eBay will have deserved it. After 16+ years on eBay I cannot believe that eBay has deteriorated like this. Treating its customers with such obviou$ callou$ di$dain is how companies go out of busine$$.
electricalley
I've been on eBay for 16+ years. A seller from whom I bought 3 items is telling me shipping is free BUT eBay is charging me USD $20+ PER ITEM for 3 small items that are being shipped together in a single box to Canada.
1-eBay's new eIS (eBay International Shipping program) does NOT allow US sellers to combine & discount shipping.
2-The US seller ships for FREE to eBay's International Hub; that's why the seller is telling me that shipping is free' because IT IS free, for HIM!
3-That means at least half of the $60+ eBay is charging me is going DIRECTLY into eBay's pocket.
4-eBay chat and phone reps insist there's no way to combine/discount shipping when using eIS.
5-Is there a BETTER way to DISCOURAGE Canadian buyers from buying on eBay! ACTUALLY, THERE IS!
6-eBay's eIS does NOT us USPS which WOULD allow sellers to combine/discount shipping; eBay uses UPS & FedEx EXCLUSIVELY.
7-Neither UPS nor FedEx will ship to PO Boxes!
8-Is there any way for eBay to further ALIENATE Canadian buyers? YES, INDEED!
9-eBay will allow Canadian buyers who use a PO Box as their Primary Address to freely BID and BUY NOW on eBay WITHOUT warning them that the eBay Checkout page will STOP them from paying for the items they just committed to buying once the Checkout process spots the PO Box address.
10-So there you have it, Canadian eBay buyers. This is the NEW REALITY on eBay.com
11-Why would ANY Canadian buyer continue to use eBay?
12-We Canadians ARE polite; we're def NOT stupid! 😛
marnotom!
If the seller is open to the idea, the way to get around eIS’s limitations on combined shipping is for them to cancel the listings in question (or sales, if the items have already been purchased) and relist them as a single listing exclusively for the buyer. It helps if the items are in the same category for customs purposes on eIS’s end.
A good example of this can be found on this thread, which also brings up another issue with eIS that you haven’t brought up:
https://community.ebay.ca/t5/Buyer-Central/DHL-is-charging-me-taxes-WTH/m-p/508822
lotzofuniquegoodies
@marnotom!
@electricalley
I have talked to numerous buyers who are, how shall we say, unthrilled with the program. I have passed on the suggestion on either a combined listing or opting out on the listings concerned. Their response from those sellers was either an outright no or zippo for a polite return response. They feel (imply) it's not worth their time and trouble. To find a seller that IS willing to cooperate/be flexible is definitely needle in a haystack like. Just has made for bad buying experience especially with the increased shipping costs, slow service and potential risk for porch pirates. There is supposed to be a video somewhere on dot com, I believe both for a seller and buyers perspective on what happens to a shipment when it gets to eIS but I have not had any luck tracking it down. (eBay supported video).
-Lotz
PS. With GSP you could go to the help page and relatively easily find out how to opt out on a by listing basis for those 1 of customers. With eIS not as easy to find. In theory eIS should have dedicated help considering it is an entity onto itself for all the frustrations it has reportly caused. (The dot ca discussion forum should never have been the go to for user help and concerns on the issue.)
-Lotz
pjcdn2005
@electricalley
Just to clarify something g that you wrote, Sellers do NOT ship free to the hub, they still have to pay for a label to ship it there. What the seller meant is that he doesn't charge buyers a separate shipping cost. He has free domestic shipping which means that he likely has ncluded the shipping cost on the item price.
Anonymous User
mrdutch1001
Comments like this shows how little buyers know and/or understand about the different shipping processes around the world, but it's especially shameful how buyers have so little knowledge about those shipping processes between USA & Canada....
Blaming eBay for a mail sortation problem in Houston, Texas is ridiculous...
theoldestfart
OPWho in this thread blamed anything on a mail sorting issue in Houston?
marnotom!
electricalley
So according to you eIS is great for Canadians? Sound like you're an eBay.com employee.
mrdutch1001
nooood..I never said that "eIS is great for Canadians "
I don't buy anything on eBay...haven't for many many years...and certainly NOT from the USA!
and oh yeah just love how you think I am an "eBay.com employee">!! what a joke!
Sorry, to dissapoint but at my age I don't/won't work for anyone but myself...
Have a good day!
C'est la vie!
Que sera, sera!
electricalley
I totally agree with you. I've ordered a cell phone on Ali that arrived in3 weeks. eBay used to deliver items to me in Canada in 1-2 weeks; now it takes 3-4+ weeks because items MUST go through eBay's Intenrational hub where they get a new and different tracking number. The whole eIS process benefits sellers (who ship free to eBay's US hub) and it benefits eBay who gets to add shipping charges that CANNOT be combined/discounted, putting extra money into eBay's pockets. Additionally, eBay's eIS will NOT ship to PO Boxes because eIS ONLY uses UPS and FedEx. So Canadian ordering items on eBay.com has become a Canadian Porch Pirate paradise! Good-bye eBay.com. Adieu!
femmefan1946
Under the CUSMA treaty of 2020 Canadians can import up to $150 value from the USA duty free,and $40 tax free.
So there should be no import fees on the purchase.
Canada Post's service charge is for collecting those import fees. No fees> no service charge.
The shipping charge is based in part on the seller's choice of shipping service, and in part on the eIS(discounted for bulk shipping) fee for shipment from Illinois to your doorstep in Canada.
Your total cost would be $47USD /$58.75.
theoldestfart
OPThat $47 USD is what I paid a fellow Canuck in NWT for the same item up here. I did notice that one eIS seller in USA had enabled the feature that you paid the import fees upfront. I forget what the cost of that item was as I have looked at so many over the past couple of days.
marnotom!
Sellers don't enable that feature, eBay does. When eIS was first unleashed, the word from eBay was that at some point buyers would get the choice as to whether they wanted to pay duties and taxes at Checkout or on delivery, but so far it seems to be mostly the latter option with the Checkout option determined by the value of the item and its category as well as other criteria that escape me at the moment.
fh991586
Shipping charge are not stated on the custom form, only the declared value of the item. So it's not accurate to think you'll be dinged with brokerage fee on the total you paid.
It's worse in Europe, as there are no more gift or small value item provision: everything not a document is taxable, thus making it a lot less interesting to sell there. If you don't pay the fee in advance, the buyer might refuse to pay them at delivery...
brettjet38
"It is no longer cost-effective to buy from US sellers."
That is the whole point, buy local within your own country, that is what Western Goverments are doing...
electricalley
There's no reason to bring MAGA politcs into this discussion.
marnotom!
How do you know that the item wouldn't just get a "free pass" from Canada Border Services when it entered Canada? How do you know your item would get a "free pass" from CBSA if it went through as a direct-mailed shipment?
Anyway, it sounds as though our governments' plans to level the playing field and keep us shopping locally are being successful. I don't see this as being an eIS issue, quite frankly.
theoldestfart
OPI certainly have never gotten a "free pass" from CBSA on any eIS items which was about 4 or 5 items. Direct mail item I would take my chances any day on direct mail shipments especially at this time of year and since these days I am buying a heck of a lot more items via AliExpress than I am via eBay. None of these were assessed as additional charges via CBSA via direct mail shipments.
I tried to purchase within Canada on eBay only to have one user never reply back to my Best Offer bid and another seller in Canada tried to do an off eBay deal.
marnotom!
I've only made one eIS-forwarded purchase so far, but I got it without a tax charge as it looks as though the C$40 tax-free limit for couriered shipments was applied rather than the C$20 tax-free limit for mailed shipments. (Yes, Canada Post handled the item within Canada. The package had a "Delivered Duties [sic] Paid" sticker on it.)
Unless somebody handling my item goofed or things have changed, the item you're referring to in your original post would have gone through tax-free, too.