Mystery PayPal Fees for Canadian Ebayer
Summary: ecumsecumguy has encountered an issue where their US credit card is charged more than expected when making purchases on eBay in US dollars, despite using a US bank account. Various entities like the bank, eBay, and PayPal are involved, each attributing the problem to the others, particularly suggesting a misinterpretation of their Canadian eBay account as leading to double currency conversion fees. marnotom! suggests considering eBay's Managed Payments and bypassing PayPal, as this may solve the currency conversion issue. The discussion highlights the complexity of currency conversions for Canadians using US payment methods on eBay, with ecumsecumguy ultimately considering "Americanizing" their eBay account to avoid these fees.
ecumsecumguy
7 comments
ypdc_dennis
In paypal what do you have set as your Primary currency? Canadian or American?
https://www.paypal.com/myaccount/money/
If using a credit card to pay directly (not through paypal) when checking out, ebay.ca will give you the option of paying with your home currency (ebay converts) or in the currency the seller is using (your credit card does any converting).
I have ebay charge my credit card in US$ for .com purchases.
My credit card is charged in US$ (my bank then converts to Canadian$ since it is a Canadian$ card).
You should have no problem paying directly in US$ with your US$ credit card with no unexpected surprises. You just have to remember that ebay has a shorter dispute time range.
-;-
marnotom!
For what it’s worth, I was given that option as well for my last US dollar purchase on eBay and I was using PayPal with a Canadian dollar credit card. I think it was PayPal giving me that option rather than eBay, though.
marnotom!
This does appear to be a case of double currency-conversion, although I can't explain why it's happening except that it probably has something to do with the cardholder being in Canada. There's a thread from a few years ago started by a user with a Canadian-issued US dollar credit card that has a possible explanation attached to it; you may want to give it a read (it's not long):
https://community.ebay.ca/t5/Buying-on-eBay/Using-a-US-Dollar-credit-card-from-Canada/qaq-p/448550
I'm curious about why you're using PayPal to make a purchase with a US dollar credit card, though. Does Managed Payments not support a direct payment from a Canadian buyer with a US dollar credit card? In other words, do you really need to use PayPal for your US dollar eBay purchases? You do have buyer protection through eBay, although it doesn't extend for as long as that of PayPal.
ecumsecumguy
OPecumsecumguy
OPmarnotom!
If you're not having this issue when you purchase from other US-based sites that don't offer PayPal as a payment method, then I'd conclude that this is a PayPal issue and it would be best to bypass them when making purchases from eBay. While eBay still accepts PayPal payments, PayPal no longer processes payments for eBay sales and it's not set up to have sellers use PayPal to receive payments anymore.
As a buyer, you're not really expected to know anything about Managed Payments except that it's now how payments are being processed for sellers. It's run by a company called Adyen, for what it's worth. Your purchases are covered by eBay's Money Back Guarantee. It works similarly to PayPal's buyer protections, but there are a few differences, particularly in the available timeframe for filing claims:
https://www.ebay.ca/help/policies/ebay-money-back-guarantee-policy/ebay-money-back-guarantee-policy?id=4210
Also keep in mind that you should have protections available through your card issuer.
I'm not surprised that you can't get much of an answer from PayPal on your issue, actually. I mean, how many Canadian buyers pay with a US dollar credit card issued by a US-based bank? It's not a situation they're going to run into that often.
While you're likely getting hit by some currency conversion fees, they'd be built into the exchange rates used to convert your payment, just as they would be if you were exchanging currency at a bank or letting your credit card do the conversion. To complicate things, because currencies have "buy" and "sell" rates that aren't the same, you end up paying more because of that.
When you view the transaction summary on PayPal, does it show any hint of currency conversion?
By the way, sellers who accept a payment from outside their country may also be subject to an "international transaction fee" depending on the buyer's country and if eBay is being used to forward the item out of the country. I'm wondering if your US sellers--if they're not using "eBay International Shipping"--are subject to this fee when you purchase from them? I'm guessing yes.
ecumsecumguy
OPI have had much online conversation and phone calls with PayPal, what an elusive and evasive bunch! I finally threw in the towel. This appeared to be very much like a Monty Python skit at the end, and indeed the parrot was dead.
You are right this is a bit of an extraordinary circumstance and it was very difficult to get them to understand the issue - they kept blaming it on the US bank which I knew already had no part of this.
Basically, what it comes down to is this I'm afraid. I registered on eBay as a Canadian years ago, and when I make a purchase it automatically assumes that I will be paying by accessing Canadian funds, and asks PayPal for payment in Canadian dollars which will need to be converted back to US funds to pay for the purchase. PayPal charges quite a hefty fee to do this, an apparently also adds on a " buyers fee" of some sort as well ( although this was badly explained by the PayPal rep). This accounts for a $1688 USD purchase being transformed into a $1833 USD charge against my US bank, even tho Canadian currency has not entered at all into the equation.
eBay advised me to stop using PayPal and also to change all of my settings that may identify me as an Canadian . I must fully "Americanize" myself apparently, although I'm a tad skeptical of this. This may be the only way to link my eBay account to my US bank account without extraordinary fees being involved.
Alternatively, PayPal suggested I resign myself to the conversion fees and abandon the US bank and draw on my Canadian bank for eBay purchases to avoid the double conversion. Interesting, as I took out an account in a US bank to avoid excessive conversion fees up here in the north, at the advice of my Canadian bank who owns the US branch.
Americanizing myself may also be necessary to avoid the same problem if I link my US card directly to my eBay account. I've got to unlink from poutine, ketchup chips and maple syrup.
Such are the convolutions of the eBay and PayPal systems. It has been both an illuminating and unwanted investigation. Much time and patience wasted.