Buyer claims item is defective. I know it's not. Issue partial refund?
Summary: A participant initiated a discussion seeking advice over a situation where a buyer claims that an item is defective, although the seller is sure it's not. They are contemplating whether to issue a partial refund in response.
I recently sold an item that I know works, yet the buyer is claiming that it does not. He has filed for a return with the reason "doesn't work or defective."
Each and every time this has happened in the past, I have had the item shipped back to me. The item has either worked perfectly fine or been damaged by the buyer.
I don't wish to issue a return label for this item, as the cost to ship it back is more than the item is worth. I have already communicated to the buyer that I would like him to provide a video of it not working and also asked him what the issue was with the original part he is replacing. They are now not replying.
My question is: am I best to issue the partial refund now, or wait it out until eBay steps in in a few days?
marnotom!
Partial refunds without returns make sense in situations such as if the buyer is claiming reparable damage or that there are missing components to the item that can be replaced. A partial refund without a return does not make sense if the buyer is claiming that the item is basically a doorstop and can't be made to function as it's supposed to function.
One of the reasons why eBay has its Money Back Guarantee is to discourage buyers from filing chargebacks, which are expensive, and labour/time-intensive to process. And one of the reasons why eBay tends to favour buyers in this sort situation is that if the buyer were to file a chargeback, they'd likely prevail in one.
Hate it say it, but you probably should have called the buyer's bluff and handled this situation the way you've handled similar ones in the past. Does their feedback left for other sellers suggest that they have a tendency to file lots of claims for non-functional merchandise?
rosscd57
Yep - what marnotom said.
Take a look at the buyers feed back all the way back to when he started and see if there is any indication that this situation or one like it has happed before. If you think it has, you then you can likely open a case. This has worked for me a couple of times in the past. I ususally get on the phone with an agent and see if I can covince the agent to sugest that I open a case.
HInt! Calling takes a while, the fastest way to contact an agent is to get on the chat line and request an agent, You may have to make the request a couple times as Bots are stupid. This way you also have hard copy of the conversation or they may switch you to a supervisor on the phone.
timelesstechtrove
OPI've asked the buyers some questions; however, they are conveniently not responding. I'm guessing they're waiting for eBay to step in (tomorrow), which may end up even worsening my position, if that's even possible; eBay really has sellers by the balls.
art-and-craft
Seller does not have any choice, other than buyer's choice/request.
So ask the buyer what they want. Let them make the choice.
If you choose a return, you may (or may not) lose "All" -- pay for return shipping and get a "defective/damaged/totally destroyed" item. It all depends on the buyer's conscience.
flipistics
Accept the return. You can choose to either require them to ship it back or not. If you wait for eBay to step in, they'll rule against you, you probably won't get the selling fees for the transaction back, and they'll give you a strike against your account.
timelesstechtrove
OPWill they reimburse the shipping both ways? The other issue is I no longer have a way to test the item once I get it back (since the original equipment it came out of was sold or disposed of) in case the seller sends back their defective one, or broke the one I sent, so I have to toss it, anyway.
flipistics
No, if they claim it's defective or an INAD, you're on the hook for the item price and the original shipping. The only question is whether or not you want to pay to have the item returned to you.
If you're a top rated seller there's additional options.
Honestly, returns are a risk you take when selling things like electronics or computer parts. You're going to deal with some fraudulent returns, and possibly some where the buyer really thinks the part is defective when it's actually due to some other problem with their device. The good sales should more than make up for the odd bad one.
recped
How does a partial refund make up for an item the buyers says it's defective?
Did your buyer ask for a partial?