Possible Decision On Tariffs Friday
Summary: The discussion titled "Possible Decision On Tariffs Friday" lacks content in all posts. Although multiple participants, such as codacloset, flipistics, and others, initiated and responded within the thread, no meaningful content or opinions regarding tariffs or related subjects are present. This resulted in a thread of empty exchanges, without any clear outcome or decision mentioned.
The Supreme Court will be making decisions on a number of cases on Friday at 10 AM ET. One of the cases that could be deciced is the tariff case. I've done some reading and from what I gather it will be very difficult for The Orange Man to recreate tariffs to override the de minimis agan if the tariffs are overturned. We could very well see sweeping tariffs levied against numerous countries and against different commodities, but it would be difficult to override the de minimis again unless some other emergency situation was fabricated (which it could be).
How much does everyone estimate the tariffs have hurt their sales? I would say my overall sales are down about 60-75%, but I started transitioning into selling items of higher value late last spring before the de minimis ended. I was previously selling a higher volume of lower price items (video games and inexpensive clothing), so it's difficult for me to compare because of how drastically I've changed what I'm selling.
Part of the thing that's been difficult is the idea of paying tariffs for American buyers. Even if I have found DDP solutions so buyers won't be charged anything additional upon delivery, it's hard to explain to someone that they won't pay duties when eBay are telling them they will. My sales for video games to the US basically died back in April last year when the Chinese de minimis ended. It didn't even make sense because all of the discs for North American games I sell are manufactured in the US or Mexico and all of the discs for the Japanese games are made in Japan. It's been an awful combination of American buyers' lack of general understanding of custom rules and regulations and eBay's vague/somewhat innacurate warning messages that are shown to buyers at checkout that were written by someone in San Jose who has no understanding about the rules.
drath999
Before the tariffs, 80% of my orders were from the U.S.A. After this, it is now about 2.5%-ish. It hurt quite a lot; however, it's hard to gauge exactly the impact, as it indirectly made Canadian buyers more likely to buy within Canada, as afterwards, I had way more Canada-based orders.
codacloset
OPI also forgot to mention, the Trump administration will probably try to take both cases to Appeals Court and maybe the Supreme Court. I would be shocked if either would hear the cases. The Supreme Court was already clear that a tariff is a tax and a President doesn't have the authority to impose a tax without Congressional approval.
codacloset
OPI'm not sure if anyone else has been following it, but the case was brought back that was filed by US auto parts distributor Detroit Axle regarding ending the de minimis. The case was put on stay by the CIT (Court of Iternational Trade) leading up to the Supreme Court decision. Detroit Axle motioned to have the stay dissolved on Feb.26th and it was approved on March 5th. The Trump administration has until the end of the day today to submit a response. I've been following the case on Court Listener and they have not submitted anything thus far. If they don't submit anything I think the CIT will automatically decide in the Plaintiff's favour (Detroit Axle). The Trump Administration seems to have given up on the case.
There's a hearing by the CIT scheduled Friday for the new global 10% tariffs. It remains unclear whether they will put an injunction on them immediately or they will wait until they make a judgment on the case. In both cases it's somewhat unlikely that they will put stays on the tariffs for them to continue to be collected.
Trump will probably introduce some punitive tariffs surrounding these new 'tariff probes', but it will be fairly immaterial for most of us if the de minimis is reinstated. It is scheduled to be rolled back in July 2027 as part of the 'One Big Beautiful Bill', but by that time it's likely Democrats will have won back the House and/or the Senate and a lot of parts of that bill will be challenged/defeated.
electronicsextraordinaire
Wait, was Detroit Axle importing most of its parts from China in <US$800 shipments at a time???
The $800 exemption is supposed to be per entity, per day... so I don't get how they benefited from that unless they sent stuff to their US warehouses by post and CBP never caught on.
Or they imported to a Canadian or Mexican warehouse and drop-shipped to the US from there? As far as I know, they only shipped from USA.
I'm happy they're taking on the de minimis fight, but would have expected them to be on the other side...
Something is missing from their story. Or they just hate any and all tariffs (wooo!)
codacloset
OPHmm, that's a good question. I do know that they have (or had) a warehouse in Mexico that they would drop ship stuff from to the US.
4biddingstuff
Yes, it's been a hard pivot with these tariffs and de - minimus cancelled. I weight it the same way the Liberal government has attacked Alberta and set boundaries on how they should produce and sell their oil and gas.
We have governments on both sides of the border making things harder for sellers. We love to tell the USA on how it should operate but we can't even get our Provinces to work together to make Canada better.
Another poster mentioned that de-minimus was going to be reviewed within 2 years and could have been cancelled or extended; we don't know.
As for the history that other poster mentioned:
"Under the Tariff Act of 1930, almost every product imported into the United States was subjected to customs and duty. This resulted in unnecessary inconvenience to customs officials for too little revenue.
In 1938, Congress developed the De Minimis rule, which refers to something too minor or trivial to merit consideration."
We didn't expect to go back to the future. Making trade harder, making customs harder and the movement of goods of any value take much longer.
You cannot spin back tariffs paid or de-minimus but I would like to see the Supreme Court say the tariffs and de-minimus cancellation must have an end date; send it back for review for any further tariff/de minimus updates and have it go back to the House and Senate for final say.
We have the Fed and Bank of Canada setting interest rates based on economics, they can do the same for de minimus and tariffs. Isn't it great how we have all these government bodies controlling everything. yeah..
rdemaree
Statistically speaking my sales were down at least by around 30% all things considered vs 2024
This is after running a different sale every month, filling my shop with entry level items, optimising my photos/ descriptions, adding a CUSMA disclaimer to ever listing etc. Literally everything that you can think of that a business would do to shore up business I have done and STILL saw nearly a 1/3 drop in sales.
The optics are what are hurting sales right now. The average person doesnt understand the nuances of trade policies. All they hear from the "president" is *international countries are terrible and if you buy from them you will pay a bigly hugely bestly kingly tariff!!!!* which isnt true in my case since most of my products are covered by CUSMA and reigstered. So much for the GOP being for the free market and lower taxes tho! Its a hidden regressive tax on the middle and lower class to justfiy tax cuts for the wealthy. That and obliterating social services.
Ebay made sure to help remedy the situation by misinforming our customers with a big blue banner telling customers they WILL have to pay tariffs (regardless), offer us the wonderful X3 more expensive and X3 slower EIS shipping program and then they also did us the favor of raising promotional listings by a mandatory 2% if you use it with no added benefit to sellers.
Its been awesome!
*Sarcasm*
We need the supreme court to strike down the tariffs (very likely) which is good optics for CUSMA sellers and will allow us all to sell foreign goods into the USA again without big fees.
We also need ebay to really recognize how bad things are right now and to do more to help sellers, which they are currently doing the opposite of right now. (promotional listing price hike, EIS, tariff warning etc.) Ebays actions right now are primarily for the benefit of ebay not sellers.
lotzofuniquegoodies
@rdemaree
@byto253
Problem being even IF they decide NOT in Trump's favour it will automagically get appealed and re-appealed until the cows come home. Best "plausible" (trying to be hopefully optimistic) would be a full stop on tariffs and bringing back de minimus until they get their ducks in row. Will this happen? ...Anyone's guess...Stay tuned to this station for further tariff alerts!!
While you are waiting in suspense for a verdict: More fun facts on alerts and/or hopefully a bit of levity to try to brighten your day/night to take your mind off this neverending insanity.
And last but not least.
flipistics
Or Trump may simply ignore it and dare anyone to stop him. Who knows what would happen in that scenario.
recped
There is no possibility of appeal when it comes to the Supreme Court "the Highest Court In The Land".
That said, Trump can just use a different justification for the tariffs and start the process all over again. There have been some suggestions that these options are ready to go with Executive Orders prepared and only needing Trumps scribble.
One thing I have not found any reliable information about is the De Minimis exemption and if it will be affected by the upcoming SCOTUS decision. I have seen some suggestions that it could go back to $800.
byto253
I don't see the de minimus being brought back. That has been in the cross hairs of several administrations. If the emergency power tariffs were over-turned I would think that it would end up reverting to the situation of the de minimus still being gone and the normal duty schedule coming into effect. I do not know the ins and outs but possibly the original 2 year timing for the de minimus being ended would come back since that was in a properly authorized bill.
fergua3
IF the tariffs are overturned, and that's a big if, i'm of the opinion that SCOTUS is firmly in Trump's back pocket now (we'll know soon), then as stated above he has claimed several work arounds to this important 'national security' requirement for tariffs. If all else fails he will just defy SCOTUS....what are they, or anyone else going to do about it?
I would not count on any positive changes coming from the US for a very, very long time.
byto253
For sure. There may be a temporary roll back in some areas, not sector specific either. And it will be messy. It could give cover/excuse for them to drop some tariffs they won't right now because that would be voluntarily backtracking. Politics -> power + the irrational.
recped
Which administrations are you talking about?
Here is some history about Di Minimis in the USA:
https://customscity.com/from-past-to-present-a-historical-overview-of-section-321-and-its-influence-on-customs-compliance/
In the 95 years that the Di Minimis exemption has existed in the USA it has never been lowered (until Trump) and has been increased many times by many administrations.
fergua3
No ruling by the Supreme Court on Friday. No big surprise there......they're still trying to figure out how they can spin a ruling in their Lord Trump's favour.
transtraders
I wouldn't be surprised the orange dingo is creating all these wars around the world just so he can declare his tarriffs are "war measures" to keep them in place.
sapphyres-designer-jewellery
I use DDP shipping, and tried to advertise as such in the listing and the title of the listing (by putting tariffs included in the title, and explaining how I ship DDP so that nothing is owed on delivery). And then after all that effort, eBay is still telling buyers that tariffs are owed on delivery of their item. I've gotten three messages in three days from buyers who are either upset because eBay says there's tariffs (when I say there isn't), or are questioning if there are tariffs due when their parcel is delivered.
I'd probably sell a lot more and things would be normal if eBay wasn't contradicting me every time they look at a listing.
C.
byto253
Nothing like being knee-capped!
mrdutch1001
"How much does everyone estimate the tariffs have hurt their sales?"
For myself, the tariffs have hurt my sales on eBay VERY little! My eBay sales in general had already dwindled to the point where eBay is no longer a viable selling site for my items and by sping of 2025 I had already started to increase my presence on my other selling site where in mid-August I also stopped shipping to the USA. That selling site has done well with Canada only customers. As for eBay going forward, I will be listing a minimal amount here on an irregular basis...
flipistics
For me, I think it only cost me about 25%. I think the Canada Post strikes and threats of labour issues actually hurt me more. The issue with the de minimis is that he'd likely pivot to applying a hefty "package processing fee" which could be much worse.