Problem with Canada Post Lettermail?
Summary: chicweb raised concerns about a significant increase in issues with Canada Post delivery times, particularly affecting customers in BC, Alberta, and Ontario. john_koenig99 and others shared similar experiences with delayed or inaccurately reported deliveries. Discussions included possible solutions like adding extra handling days, switching to tracked shipping for some categories, and adjusting business models to mitigate impact. intimewithmusic suggested transitioning away from Lettermail, citing its financial drain on Canada Post and personal business experience. Different participants debated the trade-offs between cost, service quality, and adapting to changes within Canada Post's system.
Just this week, we had 4 INR. Just by comparison, in 3 years, we only had 3 before....
Something is going on with Canada Post... We added 5 days of handling, already, and it doesn't seem to be enough.
We have to put everything with tracking to protect our account and make sure everything is delivered.
This happend to customers in BC, Alberta and Ontario.
lotzofuniquegoodies
According to CP's delivery standards for expedited (your tracked) regional from urban centres is supposed to be 1 to 4 days, National 2 to 8 days. From non urban regional is 2 to 5 days, National 4 to 12 days. If it is going to an air stage estimates are a bit all over the map. Spotted something recently where they were buffering another 2 days into those estimates.
Here are the modification details:
Delivery Guarantee Modification For items mailed between Monday, November 2 , 202 6 , and Sunday, January 1 0 , 202 Canada Post will only honour delivery guarantee claims for late delivery if an item is delivered two or more business days after the delivery standard . This adjustment will 7 , apply to Priority TM Oversize , , Xpresspost TM Unpackaged and Out and Expedited Parcel TM of spec Items services mailed within Canada.
My conjecture has always been for eBay's purposes they have been using a 1 size fits all approach average. I can drop something off on a Thursday/Friday and not see it move until the following Tuesday. Even longer if there was a holiday involved. Problem being eBay estimates are best case scenarios...not worst.
john_koenig99
One fresh case in point: I just purchased yesterday (late afternoon EDT) an item from a seller in Manitoba. The selected shipping method was Expedited CP. Estimated delivery is shown to me as November 2 to November 5. The seller's shipping policy says it ships within 1 business day of purchase (so, Monday). Will it arrive by Thursday!? I somehow doubt it. Even Expedited parcels from sellers in the GTA (where I live) usually take 2-3 business days to arrive.
chicweb
OPYes, I had to add 5 handling days just to have a somewhat "correct" estimation.... Otherwise, it shows estimations across Canada within a week, which is impossible.
intimewithmusic
I renewed my BC Drivers licence/health Care Card on July 29. ICBC told me to wait 60 days for a replacement. After 60 days no licence. It was time to vote in two elections. I scrambled for alternate ID. On investigation Canada Post lost my drivers licence in lettermail.
In 2026, putting a photo drivers licence/Canada Care Card in Canada Post's Lettermail is tantamount to leaving one on the sidewalk in front of a 7/11. Shame on you ICBC! I notified them and both Canadian credit bureau institutions who put a 6 year watch on my credit accounts. Folks, this is 2026, this is not 1990.
Frankly the "I've been selling on eBay for 20 years and never had a problem" just doesn't cut it anymore. In 10 months our neighbourhood converts to comummunity mail boxes. Mail is serious fair game. I'm converting all possible mail to paperless. No disrespect is intended to any seller who uses lettermail for $10 items BUT, If I was you and I also sell higher value items I would create a separate eBay store for that stuff unless your sales numbers are so high and your 100% seller rating is untouchable by INRs and other defects until Lettermail becomes trackable.
These days we have identity theft as a major mail theft attraction for thieves and, as well we have some educated dishonest buyers who know the game.
reallynicestamps
High value (whatever that means to the seller) items should not be sent without tracking. It's not worth the worry.
If the seller feels nervous, upgrading from the normal untracked service to a tracked service can be worth the money.
However, we can avoid Defects by settling problems before they become Claims. A seller using untracked shipping who is notified on non-delivery by the last estimated date, who puts on their big girl panties and refunds, avoids any chance of getting a Claim or an Defect.
Worst case then is that the buyer mentions the refund in feedback.
chicweb
OPINR cases still count in service metrics, even if refund are sent in time.
For untracked shipping, there's no point to wait to refund. Sellers takes the risk by sending untracked.
We fixed certain amount we are ok to risk with. Past that amount, its always with tracking.
My problem is more about how our service affects those customers, the possible lost of future sales and service metrics (account standing).
reallynicestamps
My point was to avoid the Claim by a) soothing the customer if possible when they report the problem b) refunding BEFORE the customer opens a Claim.
And while we all (I hope) try to give the best service possible, possible is not going to be perfect, because some people prefer to complain rather than be made whole.
intimewithmusic
Yes @chicweb The solution is to reshape your business model to stop using Lettermail.
chicweb
OPNo. This model worked for 3 years.
At the moment, it seems to be coincidences. Some product categories might switch to tracking.
But low value items cannot and there's demand for this.
One thing I might try is to offer Express service also with table rate. So offering both might give more choices to customers.
intimewithmusic
This is just an observation. Not trying to be argumentive. Instead of looking back 3 years you might look ahead and gradually transition to tracked services.
Here's why. We all know about CPs dumpster fire. Changes are currently in effect replacing home delivery with community boxes. So what's CP got coming next? This has been public now for a couple of years.
```````
[AI Summary of the crisis]
Canada Post loses money overall on Lettermail operations, and this deficit is deeply compounded by online sellers exploiting the system to ship merchandise instead of paper correspondence.
Because Canada Post is mandated by its universal service obligation to deliver to every Canadian household, it is legally barred from refusing a letter based on whether the sender is writing a note or packing a cheap item. Online sellers frequently take advantage of this by mailing flat, inexpensive goods (like enamel pins, stickers, video games, or thin clothing) as "Oversize Lettermail". This costs a fraction of the price of an actual parcel. [1, 2, 3, 4]
The financial dynamics explain why this is a major loss leader for Canada Post:
1. Massive Pricing Deficit
The operational infrastructure required to manually sort, transport, and deliver a thin item costs far more than the postage rate collected. For perspective, shipping an "Oversize Lettermail" item weighing under 100 grams nationwide costs less than $3.00. By contrast, shipping the exact same item as a tracked Parcel usually starts around $10 to $15. Canada Post absorbs that immense revenue gap while bearing the same sorting and transportation labor. [1, 2]
2. Manual Labor Bottlenecks
Canada Post relies heavily on high-speed automated sorting machines designed for flat, flexible paper envelopes. Small pieces of merchandise (like hard plastic charms, lumpy jewelry, or keychains) jam these machines, damaging equipment or destroying the mail. Consequently, lettermail items containing rigid merchandise frequently have to be manually culled and hand-sorted by postal workers. Hand-sorting is incredibly slow and labor-intensive, destroying any slim profit margin on a $2–$3 stamp. [1]
3. The Bigger Financial Picture
The Macro Drain: Transaction Mail (Lettermail) revenue dropped a staggering 13.7% in a single quarter recently, part of a systemic drop from peak volumes in 2006. [1, 2]
Unsustainable Losses: Canada Post recorded an historic pre-tax loss of $1.57 billion in 2025. Because they are hemorrhaging parcel market share to private delivery networks (dropping from 62% in 2019 to just 24% by 2024), they no longer have enough profitable commercial parcel revenue to subsidize the losses incurred on the Lettermail side. [1, 2]
In short, while using Lettermail to ship merchandise is a highly profitable loophole for small e-commerce businesses, it functions as an operational and financial drain on Canada Post's bottom line. [1]
``````````````````
The question is should we drive the bus until it goes over a cliff or change the direction?
chicweb
OPIn fact, We will gradually, yes.
I decided today that Comic books can be sent using Expedited Lite without too much of a difference in price. Maybe 2$ more of what we were charging for shipping.
So this is the kind of products that can transition... We have more than 1.5k comics and we haven't added the third of what we have in inventory.... So I'm happy to be able to switch that entire category to tracking. It shouldn't hurt too much the business.
The only problem is with DVD, CD and Magazines. But only bought in singles. When buing multiple, we automatically send with tracking. So it will be limited.
I'll think of something. But I've already created a promo with Buy x Get Y free... To try to push buying multiples. So, I'll think of other ways to try to promote multiple items sales.
intimewithmusic
@reallynicestamps I agree with you on a lot of things but not this. You enjoy a lot of regular customers most of whom are very used to the postal system. Given that and the fact at least half of us don't wear "big girl panties" {OK that's funny and I'm kidding] ..it's what you sell and who you sell to that makes lettermail relevant or not.
My Definition of "High Value"
High value is anything above what you would care less about losing in the mail or having stolen by an educated buyer.
High value is what you value your time is worth to troubleshoot with CP and eBay over Lettermail late delivery or INR Buyer issues. Do you actually hve time over a lost $10 item ($8 after PL and FVs) to "settle problems before they become Claims"?
High value is anything that sells for more than the cost of it's own tracked shipping.
High value is what costs you enough grief or concern to post about in the eBay forum.
I personally would not order anything sent lettermail. I'm not the only one. I understand the romance of paying $3 postage for a $10 item back in 1963 when I ordered xray glasses and stamps from the back of Batman comics. I know this annoys some. No need to send your hate mail. Bin there dun that. This is lettermail, not world peace. You do you.
SOMEONE has to speak up for us, the lettermail non user guys. New sellers read this forum and scratch their heads wondering if lettermail is a professional service to promote your brand deserve both perspectives. Well it depends on what you sell, who you sell to and most important, just how many $5-$10 widgets you can peddle per hour to justify your time after fees and settling problems. BC's minimum wage is $18.25 an hour. That's a whole lot of LVIs.
I don't need "big girl panties"because I've only done 1 or 2 refunds in my 13 years on eBay. That has to do with accurate listings and not using Lettermail. It's 2026 not 1990. Well... in my case not 1963 although I still have those xray glasses. I use them regularly so watch out sellers ...I'll know if you've put on those 'big girl panties".
reallynicestamps
Before you raise your shipping prices, look at your numbers.
You sold about 175 items in October.
You had four INR -- in three years -- all in the past week.
While that is odd, remember that your items are mostly under $15 and about $20 with shipping.
And that losses to refunds (whatever the reason) are tax deductible.
It could be pure coincidence.
You could ask the PO where you mail if there was a problem the day(s) you shipped.
You could change POs or postboxes.
You could review the Claims for coincidences (all the customers had 0 FB or were all named John or were PO boxes).
You could switch from Calculated Shipping to Fixed Price /Free Shipping, hiding the difference in your costs and your charges.
You could realize that not every transaction will go perfectly.
While any loss or refund is painful, how much did you actually lose?
Normally it is only procurement cost+ eBay (etc) fees+ shipping costs. Not your gross profit.
And of course the time you spend working and /or agonizing over it.
Here in BC the minimum wage is 29c a minute. Compare that to how much you spent on these annoying claims.
chicweb
OPThe problem is not really with the loss. It's more about the percieved quality of our service by that customer.
We always always always ship the next day. No exceptions. So it is difficult to cope with the fact that we do everything correctly but it still happen.
But you are right. We must focus on what we can control. Coincidences happens, and it is how we react to it that is important.
chicweb
OPThis might be related to the Estimation date bug being all over the place again....
Still not fixed. Handling time not being calculated and the estimations are way too aggresive.
We are going into the holiday season, delays will get worse and worse.
john_koenig99
I don't know if it's related to these delays in letter mail delivery but even tracked packets are taking longer than expected.
And, in some cases, the parcels are marked as delayed when, in fact, they've been delivered- this happened to me with a couple of orders. I received them and left positive feedback for the seller, but the CP (and therefore the eBay) tracking are still showing delayed, four days after they were delivered to me.