From eBay -
"Sellers can submit a limited number of requests to buyers to revise neutral or negative Feedback. The number of requests is determined by the number of Feedback comments received in the previous year. Five revision requests are allowed for every 1000 Feedback ratings given."
Maybe you do have a couple requests remaining?
Anyway, I know that I have learned never to request feedback revision for a neutral- it does nothing to affect your biz the way a neg does.
And I never submit a feedback revision to a buyer unless I am sure he will revise it after lengthy conversations, etc.
My only neg on my score right now was from some goof that could hardly even write a legible email...he said he might remove the neg if I replaced the item with a slightly wider measurement, which he knew was impossible and absolutely stupid to begin with. I think he was just mad about spending so much money- the item was down right gorgeous, and I'm sure he knows that he had no right to leave a neg.
I told him, remove the neg first, then we will involve the two companies necessary to effect a replacement. No reply.
Thats fine, I will keep his 750 bucks, I blocked him, and moved on, and will save the revision for a more deserving situation.
Still cant believe that negs stay there for one full year even for the best of sellers. What BS. And the idiot buyers are allowed to buy one item like this guy above for example, every couple of years and leave negs for us hardworking sellers that mar our record for 12 months that we strive so hard to maintain. Something wrong with this eBay picture? I think so.