01-06-2013 11:12 AM
Below is a letter written by a well informed friend of mine. He is a teacher of 30 years. He is probably the most knowledgeable individual that I know when it comes to current affairs, politics and the world siutation. He is meticulous in his research. The letter is in response to a column in the Londoner:
For several years now I have read your weekly column in the Londoner and found it always to be the voice of reason and logic.
I don't wish to disparage the paper but it is often the only column I find in this publication worth my time to peruse. That is why I was most surprised by the stance you took in your last article: Chief deserves a meeting with the PM.
Columnist Christina Blizzard provided sobering details which suggested otherwise in her Saturday, January 21st, 2012 column in the London Free Press: Help is there, Attawapiskat must step up (E2). Since 2008 De Beers has given the reserve $10 - 11 million in direct payments to the chief. Under the impact-benefit agreement (IBA) the company is not allowed to reveal the full amount it pays into the trust fund. Neither would Chief Theresa Spence reveal those details when Ms Blizzard requested clarification. As Ms Blizzard pointed out in the aforementioned column, what is known is that $325 million in contracts have been awarded to the wholly owned Attawapiskat businesses or joint ventures to date. This for an on reserve population of merely 1,549 (2011 figures: Wikipedia). Last year alone, the reserve got $51 million in contracts. Your article did not reference these sizeable sources of funding, only the $90 million the federal government additionally gave and for which disbursement of funds Spence refuses to give an auditing.
Neither did you point out as Kris Sims did (Spence, kin made $221K+ in a year. London Free Press: 4 January 2013: B2) that she and her partner made some $250,000 last year alone. Nor, did you point out as MACLEAN'S magazine revealed this week (Hungry for change: 14 Jan. 2013: 11) that Theresa Spence is using a Facebook account as a global vehicle for donations to go directly into the account of her partner, Clayton Kennedy, co-manager of Attawapiskat. And how will those undoubtedly sizeable global contributions be dispersed or audited if the Canadian people themselves are not permitted to know how their own enormous outlays for the Attawapiskat reserve were spent?
In your article on Thursday, you allude to the larger problem of some 100 out of the Canadian reserves being in dire poverty but not to the fact that 80 First Nations band chiefs and council members raked in more income in 2008 and 2009 than the Prime Minister himself and that more than 220 paid themselves more than their respective provincial Premiers earn (Chiefs' pay raises taxpayer ire. London Free Press. 23 Nov. 2010: B3). Additionally, more than 704 reserve politicians made more than $100,000 though the average population of First Nations reserves was merely 1,142 as that same article highlighted.
In short, for the first time in my acquaintance I believe you betrayed your journalistic integrity. Possibly, it was because you mention members of your family and friends being First Nations people?
I would agree with Herman Gooden (Attawapiskat chief fronts a movement stuck in neutral. London Free Press. 5 January 2013: E2) that Theresa Spence is practicing "a kind of emotional blackmail." Likewise, you are as well by your careful editing out of salient details necessary for your readers understanding. Your article was is a true example of demagoguery. And in light of your other journalistic efforts, I find that a source of true regret.
01-07-2013 05:24 PM
Today’s reality, however, is so far removed in actual day-to-day terms from the memories inside the dream palace as to be almost unbearable. The obvious conflict between reality and dream pulls some aboriginals to warrior societies; others to a rejection of dealing with the “Crown” at all; others to fights for the restoration of “rights” that, even if defined, would make little tangible difference in the lives of aboriginal people; and still others, such as Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence, to go on a hunger strike.
True, it is the reality………however……..how has this ‘reality’ all come about?
In history which we can learn from, or suffer to repeat, there have been many societies that have been overrun, controlled and dominated by others. That was their ‘reality’, but that ‘reality’ is only in the minds of those who control them…..because 'their reality' is exactly what they want...slow total control.
The 'conquerer's definition of 'reality' can be defined as ….give up! But proud people in other countries in history and up to and including the First Nations people of Canada….refuse to be destroyed, controlled or manipulated.
The thing about most people in Canada is they have never felt this feeling because they have never gone through it themselves. Some people have had relatives who when faced with tyranny they fled their homes and homeland to come to N. America. But where do the Native people flee to? This is their land and they should be treated with respect. Others may want to be absorbed and integrated into another society but many do not and they have that human right!
From the onset longggg ago the First Nations people have had to deal with people and governments that made the rules and regulations that they were forced to live by. Some of these rules ruined and nearly destroyed their fabric of life from traditions to families and that destruction in many ways has come back to haunt them. Then today between the many sections and sub-sections of rules and regulations and the government and corporate need for more land the Native people are being slowly forced out….again.
It is amazing that we can mobilize a force of men and women to go to war and we have money for everything from jet planes to fake lakes and bathrooms out in the middle of nowhere and it can all be done in a short period of time. But when Natives on Reservations need help …..they have to go through a mountain of paperwork and government departments and politicians and beaurcrats for months and years just to get minor things done, even a school for kids.
The answer is .......life is simple….it’s people and governments who make the disasters.
To imagine that isolated communities of a thousand or so people can be vibrant and self-sustaining, capable of discharging the panoply of responsibilities of “sovereignty,” is to live within the dream palace of memory.
Why? We are one of the richest countries in the world. We have the second largest oil reserves in the world (unless Harper sells it all of)….we can spend millions hosting a one week event in Vancouver and millions holding meetings for the rich and famous and the list of more is long. There is no reason that isolated communities cannot be vibrant and self sustaining and children on those reserves cannot have as good an education as other children and homes can be warm and healthy and doctors and nurses can be there to help people. No reason at all…….except complacency by those in governmental power and the people who support them.
The First Nations people have been through enough.
01-07-2013 05:31 PM
There have been many comments on thesew forums about government waste and mis-spending. The gazebo has been mentioned a hundred times.
You're right, the gazebo has been mentioned many times. Although my impression is that there is a smug minority who chime in with "what about adscam... blah, blah, blah..." every time some of these examples are brought forward.
But again, be it adscam, gazebos, $16 orange juice or Attawapiskat contracts (notwithstanding that I would have to see a lot more about Attawapiskat before deciding for myself on that one) - these are easy targets and attract the pundits like flies. Especially partisan flies.
But how about indignant media broadsides over corporate manipulation of politics and the media? That is what I would like to see and obviously will not be seeing any time soon. LOL. But can still hope for a little more of it on CTS!
01-07-2013 05:41 PM
Aboriginal terrorism
Idle No More protesters accused of 'dangerous' rail signal tampering
Canadian National Railway Police are investigating a dangerous case of tampering with crossing signals during an aboriginal blockade of a rail line east of Belleville, Ont., over the weekend.
CN spokesman Jim Feeny said railway staff witnessed the tampering Saturday afternoon after protesters went to the same location "where Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte had blockaded the week before."
"They were observed going to the crossing signals, tampering with them," Feeny said. "The crossing signals were then activated and then subsequently a fire was lit - first on the tracks, but then moved to the side of the tracks."
Feeny said innocent people could be killed in any accident caused by railway signals that aren't working properly.
"It's a serious issue for us because tampering with signals of any kind is illegal and poses a great threat to the public," he said. "We have to have absolute confidence that our signals are working perfectly in order to be able to operate
01-07-2013 05:42 PM
You're right, the gazebo has been mentioned many times. Although my impression is that there is a smug minority who chime in with "what about adscam... blah, blah, blah..." every time some of these examples are brought forward.
The reason that adscam comes up is that some on here would like to believe that the only government in Canada that has done things wrong is Harper' Conservative government. I cannot recall a government in Canada, either Liberal or Conservative that has not had its share of scandal and mis-spending. And you can add the NDP to that list if you go to the Provincial level. We have been screwed royally by one and all.
01-07-2013 06:02 PM
I cannot recall a government in Canada, either Liberal or Conservative that has not had its share of scandal and mis-spending. And you can add the NDP to that list...
This just gives the impression that you think since all are wrong in some way, they must be equally wrong.
Not true and somewhat of a cop-out.
It's like the "is smoking bad for the health controversy". Or global warming. Once you create the illusion that there is difference of opinion - both sides of the question somehow gain legitimacy - even if all logic and thoughtful consideration suggest otherwise...
01-07-2013 06:08 PM
"... it's perfectly normal for Muskoka to have $50 mil ladled out of the trough in sweetheart deals building outhouses, gazebos and other less substantial stuff... No sense."
I wish to assure those concerned, that the Summit Center located in Huntsville adjacent to the High School is being maintained to a very high standard, and is being used both day and night. I will try to take severl photos the next time I get to Huntsville so that you may feel a sense of pride, knowing your tax dollars were invested in a beautiful facility.
01-07-2013 06:10 PM
In addition, the new Firehall (Station 3) located in nearby Port Sydney, which was partially funded with your tax dollars, is also a very fine structure that is also being maintained in a pristine state.
01-07-2013 06:17 PM
they must be equally wrong.
I have always been of the opinion that we, the taxpayers, only find about a small portion of the things that governments do. Is wasting a billion dollars different than stealing a million dollars? One is based on thinking the public is stupid and gullible. The other is a criminal act.
01-07-2013 06:18 PM
unsubstantiated Attawapiskat innuendo
That is like saying you need to be hit by a truck before you will believe that trucks actually exist. It would appear that we are well beyond "innuendo".
Mismanagement is failing to keep proper financial records according to accepted accounting procedures. Revenue Canada expects me to keep accurate records of my business - or any business in Canada, for that matter.
The natives are getting money from the Canadian government. Do they feel that they do not ned to account for that money?
Natives can block a rail line or a highway or an international bridge. If you or I did that, we would be in the back of a cruiser before we knew what hit us. Do natives want to be part of Canada or not? Their actions lead me to believe that they want every benefit of being a Canadian - but none of the responsibilities.
The horrible consequences of expressing sentiments like that could very well lead to the writer achieving mention on somebody's little private dockside hate forum. And even getting a personal invitation to go there whether or not he has a boat.
01-07-2013 06:34 PM
Am I racist?
I belong to a men's social group. We go out to a rec center every other Saturday - swim, sauna, hot tub. Afterwards, some of us go for something to eat (and non-drivers, a drink). Last Saturday, I picked up Alex and John and was their driver for the evening. In the hot tub, Alex and I talked about all kinds of political and current issues. Afterwards, Alex and I and several others sat together at a retaurant and chatted for another two hours. Afterwards, I drove John and Alex home.
I was going to post this two days ago but thought a certain person would not believe me. You see, Alex is a native. I had forgotten that. To me he is just a friend. I never think of him as native; he is just Alex.
Oh, if anyone in the group should feel like an outsider, it is me. I am the only guy in the group who is not gay. However, no one thinks twice about my being part of the group.
01-07-2013 06:39 PM
Is wasting a billion dollars different than stealing a million dollars? One is based on thinking the public is stupid and gullible. The other is a criminal act.
Not really appropriate - I can't believe you would presume there were no criminal acts by the gov't in the G8 fiasco.
Not to mention arresting more people than got arrested during the October Crisis while CTV ran a loop of a burning cop car repeating every 30 seconds for hours and hours...
Never mind vote fraud, voter suppression, contempt of Parliament, etc., etc...
01-07-2013 06:51 PM
I can't believe you would presume there were no criminal acts by the gov't in the G8 fiasco.
In my opinion, the illegal acts were perpetrated by a Toronto police force, the RCMP and the OPP that got carried away with what they thought was their authority.
Never mind vote fraud, voter suppression, contempt of Parliament, etc., etc...
Two of those things have not been proven in a court of law. The last is not considered a criminal act. Maybe despicable, but not illegal. Of course, the Ontario Liberals seemed to have dissolved the Provincial Legislature and gone into hiding because of allegations against one of their members.
01-07-2013 06:58 PM
Am I racist?
Am I? According to Somebody here who has a self-conferred Diploma in Racist Determination, I am. It gets worse than this, of course. A former poster here, "Sparky" was accused of being a racist, and a mob was formed to harass him on CTS. So he left.
A Greyhound bus driver was accused of being a racist by the same Somebody. Of course, the reality is that that Somebody is actually a Nobody, and his dockside posts reveal his true character.
01-07-2013 07:09 PM
I can't believe you would presume there were no criminal acts by the gov't in the G8 fiasco.
In my opinion, the illegal acts were perpetrated by a Toronto police force, the RCMP and the OPP that got carried away with what they thought was their authority.
Knowing what was spent, knowing that previous similar events put on by Jean Chretien and others cost a tiny fraction, knowing that such extravaganzas as the Royal wedding in London and other security nightmares cost relatively far less, knowing how pathetic a job was done of accounting and tendering by Harper's G8 organizers... I am quite surprised that you would be so eager to leap to the unlikely conclusion that there was nothing illegal done by the gov't.
01-07-2013 07:11 PM
is he part Native or full and what tribe
Full/Six Nations rez near Brantford, but now lives in London.
But if their white daughter brings home a Black boyfriend.......that's a whole different kettle of fish.
My oldest was going to marry a native girl. Was I upset about that? No. I was upset that they were both under 20 and she was a drug addict. The end result was that they got pregnant (takes two). Due to her continued drug use, the baby (a boy) was born premature, lived for six weeks, then died. At that point, she left my son. It was an upsetting time for all. He weighed slightly less than a pound at birth. I can still remember his tiny little hand wrapped around my finger. I have rarely cried in my lifetime........................
01-07-2013 07:40 PM
Puck, my deepest sympathies on the loss of your grandson.
R.I.P. tiny angel. A grandfather never forgets.
01-07-2013 07:42 PM
then she taught them what was deep down inside. No biggie....it's a common thing.
I think I learned from my parents that everyone should be treated as equals. As you have said, we hear the words, but we learn by example. I lived in a neighbourhood in Vancouver that had roughly equal inhabtants - white, Chinese and Hindu. There was considerable friction between the whites and the Hindus - and between the Chinese and the Hindus. Yet, my parents seemed to get along with everyone. When my father passed away, I was amazed at the people who came to his funeral. There was a mixture of races and nationalities. There were also people who had worked with him at various times over the years. Some hadn't seen him for 30 years, but saw his name in the paper and came to the funeral.
As a youngster, starting at about age 10, I did odd jobs for the Chiese gentleman who owned the Farway Food Market on Victoria Drive in Vancouver. I spent a lot of time with his family. We used to go to Chinatown every morning before I went to school. On a daily basis, I was immersed in the daily lives of the Chinese. We ate breakfast at the Yik Fung Tea Room on Pender Street. The menus were on strips of paper on the wall - in Chinese characters. It was an eye opening experience. I worked for Johnny (the store owner) part time until I left high school.
Today, I sit at one of the picnic tables outside our apartment and visit with people from at least 15 different countries. We talk - sometimes it is difficult because I don't speak their language and they are just learning English. I learn many things about them - and they learn about me.
01-07-2013 08:43 PM
Thanks, Almond_t.
It was the best six weeks of my life and the worst.
We were there every day. His mother bottle fed him for a few days and then she disappeared. She would show up every three or four days. I can understand that she was probably scared. The baby was very fragile and so tiny. I think she may have thought he might die and did not want to get to attached to him. Unfortunately, her presence might have helped him (and might not). We will never know.
My wife and I did a lot of the feeding. By the time he passed away, we were totally in love with him. Not a day goes by that we don't think of him.
In my heart, I think he is better off. I am not sure what kind of a life he would have lead. An addict for a mother. A father whose attitude, to this day is that he doesn't want to settle down. When he broke up with his last girlfriend. He told me - "she wanted to have kids - I still want to be a kid". Very insightful on his part.
01-07-2013 09:08 PM
My condolences about your grandchild puck. I knew a Native man who was going with a white woman. He had cleaned his act up years before and thought he could help her get clean. They were going to have a child but because of the woman’s drug problems it never even made it into the world (4 days short). Drugs are a horrible thing….not just hard drugs but including alcohol and it permeates all of our society and all races and religions.
01-07-2013 09:27 PM
(It was the best six weeks of my life and the worst.)
It's a lot to go through, and I hope both you and your wife have found peace in memories.