11-07-2019 11:14 AM
I have heard many people saying that, with the new marketplace model emerging in eBay, Amazon and other global sites, the 'good ol'days' of Ebay low-start auctions are gone for good. Many sellers has had bad experiences with low-start auctions: few views, few watchers, few bids. And eventually, items going for 1 cent with just one bid. Add free shipping on top of this and your heading into real nightmare stories.
But as a seller using these low-start auctions, I still have a different take on the matter. And I'd like to share that with you. Keep in mind that I sell in the Collectible TCG cards category. What I suggest in this post may not apply to your situation or the category you're selling in.
First off, I think that the situation I underlined in the first few lines is partially true : the best days of auction-style listings may indeed be gone for good. But I still think they are worth running. But. There's a but. There are a number of good reasons to give it a shot, but also good practices to follow and proper conditions to reunite in order to succeed with LSAs these days.
First, let me start with the HUGE appeal of LSAs in my eyes. And its all psychological. LSAs are so darn EXCITING. I really think this is a strong factor that has made eBay unique and appealing from the start. BIN listings are useful and highly effective but... they're so boring.
So the main reason I still want to incorporate LSAs in my selling strategy is because they're exciting. And I love to bring excitement to the Ebay game.
Having said that, here's a couple of DO'S and DON'TS when approaching LSAs.
- Charge realistic shipping. Do not go free shipping with these. If you're going to take a loss, take it on a single side, not both sides.
- Build a customer base and be sure to have a certain number of loyal customers and/or followers, before running LSAs. You could also use LSAs to build a community of followers and increase your positive feedback. But then you need to accept that you will run on a lower profit margin on these items, and maybe take a couple of loss here and there. But once you have many people following you, your LSAs will see more activity, sell better, and sell more consistently.
- This one is really important : always keep in mind how much of your money "is tied" to the object. How did you paid for it or invested in it? Did you got it at a very low price? Was it part of a bigger lot, making the cost of this specific object very low? Did you got it for free? Also, what is the cost (real cost, as well as psychological or emotional cost) of keeping this object : maybe it takes your precious space, or it's in your way, it collect dust, its not a product you value anymore or that you want to specialize in, it is costly to keep, etc...
- If you don't have too much money tied into the object and think about starting at 99 cent, think again, and consider starting it at 1 cent instead. Both ways, you taking the risk of a loss. But 1 cent auction almost always generate more interest and more bids in the end (although not always higher final price). Starting at 1 cent, you will get the most of the "excitement" factor that I just talked about.
- Another advantage of using the auction format, is that it guarantees a money entrance at a specific moment that you can choose. It's not like BIN format, where an item can sit for month without selling. And the more regularly you run auctions, the more regularly you get incomes.
- Make sure the objects you want to try LSAs with, are not common or commodity objects. The items need to be desirable, rare, one-of-kind or collectible in some way. Uniqueness and intrinsic desirability are important factors when deciding if an object should be listed (and have a chance to perform) as LSA.
- Research, reseach, research. This is absolutely crucial in identifying the right items. Search both current and ended auctions. Using both Ebay and Terapeak (to benefit 1 full year of sold items data).
- And finally, completely forget about reserve price. Its a huge turn-off. I think Ebay should have removed this feature years ago. Put a reserve and potential buyers will just run away. It kills the excitement, and you don't want that. Instead of using a reserve price, start higher or use the BIN format/best offer.
This may sound at odds with current online marketplace tendencies, but as an eBay buyer and seller, I still believe in the usefulness - and excitement - of LSAs!
11-07-2019 11:20 AM
There was a podcast on eBay dot com recently discussing the concept of pricing. Some good ideas. Others not so good. Certains things just don't work as well on dot ca environment so difficult to apply. Still an interesting listen.
-Lotz
11-07-2019 01:09 PM
To my mind the biggest problems with LSAs are peripherally addressed in your very sensible guidelines.
My big concern with Auctions is that eBay defaults naive newbies into using Auctions and encourages low starting prices, leading to shocked and angry sellers. And a bad experience for honest buyers who bid a reasonable price, but had their purchase cancelled when they were the only bidder.
EBay's brand has been auctions. It may be the last of the online generalist auction sites. But it is irresponsible to push new sellers into the format, which is chancy at the best of times, because 'chancy' is the excitement of auction bidding.
11-07-2019 01:27 PM - edited 11-07-2019 01:28 PM
In the good old days when everything was auctions....
It was my choice to do it my way.... at my start price
and.... I always made money on everyhing I sold
Starting something at $1.00 is suicide... for the collectables, toys, dinnerware, and everthing else I sold... in those auction days... For some categories GTC will always be a better option than auctions.
---------------------------
Today I sell books and only books.... it was a few weeks ago that a seller sold several unique books at auction... Final prices were from $10 to $25 .
I sold these same books... GTC... for $35.00 each....
Auctions can be an option... today... but... auctions must be for some very specific items... and be run very carefully!
11-07-2019 02:53 PM
I think whether or not auctions have a place depends on what it is that you are selling for certain.
In my (stamp) world, I believe auctions have a place. I utilize them differently than many, and my current style is serving its purpose. (I do not use 99c starting auctions)
I do think if you have an item that has a lot of interest, starting low does generate more activity, and the more activity an item has the more visibility eBay gives to it. I have for sure seen this myself in my category for items that I've started "low" compared to the final selling price.
However I think there is also another risk with 1c/99c items: If something should sell for $10 normally, and one person buys it for 99c and another for $20 the odds are higher the person that pays 99c is the one that will complain.
I agree with femme that the marketing from ebay does not help new folks understand the inherent risk in starting things low and the current educational experience for the new seller as a result is an expensive and frustrating one as they acquire knowledge about what/how to sell.
11-07-2019 06:35 PM
the person that pays 99c is the one that will complain.
A dotCOM seller used to call those "armed bargain hunters".
The lower the price the more likely the buyer is to find fault.
With the item, with the seller, with the packaging, with the price, with the tracking.
11-09-2019 04:37 AM - edited 11-09-2019 04:53 AM
11-11-2019 09:25 AM
Thanks for your comment, reallynicestamps.
You're absolutely right with your 5 statements. Maybe I didn't emphasized it enough, but a seller really need to know the market for his products, and have a lot of feedback and followers to have some success. Also, I didn't mean that a seller should rely entirely on LSAs as a business model; he clearly shouldn't (as the risks would be extremely high, and it would probably lead to loss, frustration and disappointment).
In my case, I choose LSAs for some non-mint/imperfect items (described as precisely as possible), for lower value items that I bundle in lots - and for which I know it woulnd work well to sell them individually as BIN or auction. I also may choose LSA for items that I own, but that I don't want to specialize in, or keep any longer in my inventory (in other words, rotate the stock).
I generally agree with the "armed bargain hunters" argument. Regarding this, I would say that its absolutely crucial to maintain the same level of excellent customer service with those customers who manage to "steal" your item at a very low price on LSAs. You may grit your teeth when this happens, but it should in no way reflect in custumer service associated with this item. 🙂