01-26-2013 12:11 PM
Should the Idle No More movement be rebranded the Anti-Transparency Coalition?
When we look at what’s going on now, the question becomes quite relevant.
Six weeks ago, many of us wondered why the chief of Attawapiskat, Theresa Spence, started her so-called hunger strike/diet.
We’re still wondering with her shifting demands. She wanted a meeting with the prime minister and the governor general. When they agreed to meet — but not at the same time — she decided not to show up and kept eating her fish bouillon.
Was Spence trying to become the symbol of an Aboriginal awakening or, less nobly, trying to divert attention from what’s happening on reserves?
Less than a month before the “crisis” started, the federal government adopted Bill C-27, the First Nations Financial Transparency Act, to ensure that leaders of those communities are held to the same laws of accountability and transparency as all other elected public officials.
It’s the kind of legislation that will ensure that we find out as taxpayers how, for example, Spence’s band spent over 100 million public dollars over the last seven years managing a community of 300 families.
We won’t need a Deloitte audit in future to figure out that more than 80% of the spending is made with insufficient or no paperwork at all.
But solidarity is always stronger when you have comrades. Enter the unions.
Canadian unions fought unsuccessfully during 2012 to kill an act to also force them to open their books so the public could see how much they spend on political causes. The bill passed last December.
Well-fed Aboriginal elites and union bosses have a common enemy — the Conservative government that is threatening their rich and famous lifestyle. They felt the need to express their frustration.
Is it possible they decided to use the teepee, the drums and Spence as props to undermine those who requested transparency?
Could they have then turned to the CBC to spread their propaganda? Our national broadcaster is no friend of transparency. The CBC was forced against its will to comply with the Access to Information Act launched by the Conservatives in 2007. It challenged the Canadian information commissioner’s requests and lost in court in 2010, and in appeal in 2011.
I am mentioning this not because I want to become a conspiracy theorist, but because the Idle No More movement reminds me too much of what happened last year with the student crisis in Quebec. The left wanted to get their Parti Quebecois allies in power. The unions funded students’ associations while the CBC spread their message.
Currently in Quebec, the former red squares (carres rouges) are transforming themselves into red feathers. They rally at Place Emilie-Gamelin, where the Maple Spring all started. Will we soon find out that unions are once again secretly paying the bills? Unions are already distributing their brochures at Aboriginal protests in Ottawa and carrying their signs in Winnipeg marches.
There is hope, however: 49% of Canadians and 52% of Aboriginals oppose the Idle No More movement. Millions of Canadians clearly want no part of the anti-transparency coalition.
01-26-2013 01:06 PM
Unions secretly behind Idle No More movement ......Seems a little far fetched to me.
01-26-2013 01:09 PM
They were probably not behind the movement in the beginning. However, are they now supporting and facilitating Idle No More to promote their own agenda.
01-26-2013 04:04 PM
They were probably not behind the movement in the beginning. However, are they now supporting and facilitating Idle No More to promote their own agenda.
Many countries joined England during the war.....even the US finally came in. When people have a common enemy....it often happens. It's called a Fasces, from the latin fascis meaning 'bundle of sticks' during the Roman days. (the Romans had an axe handle and axe head wrapped as well in the bundle). It means 'strength throught unity'. The enemy may be able to break one stick but it is much more difficult if not impossible to break a bundle.
01-26-2013 07:01 PM
Who is the "enemy" ?
01-26-2013 07:17 PM
01-26-2013 07:45 PM
Who is the "enemy" ?
the Contra's on the Greyhound bus. They are easy to spot though, cause of all the boa constrictors they wear.
01-26-2013 08:32 PM
"
the Contra's on the Greyhound bus. They are easy to spot though, cause of all the boa constrictors they wear. " - sometimes I wish eBay had a LIKE button!
01-26-2013 10:17 PM
I've heard that Unions are going to have to open up their books this year.
Not sure if its rumour or fact.
If it is indeed fact this could be very interesting.
01-26-2013 10:32 PM
I would find that interesting, even though I'm completely unbiased and objective when it comes to Unions. Being impartial and equanimous is a heavy burden to bear, but I'm not complaining.
01-27-2013 11:41 AM
Ok watch another documentary today on cbc and i think i get it as a whole now ....
The way I see things now is a little different but the same in a way..
Native communities have to become more self sustainable like the Osoyoos reserve...
the only good relations between the goverment and the natives is business relations...
this country needs to help but they truly do need to help themselves as well in order for everything to work ..
Is is evident natives were very much taken advantage of due to there lack of knowledge and know how when making most deal in history ...
Canada needs to work with natives to first helping them reserve their land rights they next not giving them money but helping each and every reserve find ways for being self sustainable and producing jobs within the community ..
The Chief of the reserve mentioned earlier in post even said now with thier golf course and vineyard they have alot of decent paying jobs and life is alot better their sense anddddddddddd not losing there way of life or beliefs..
I know they have suffered alot but it is time for Canada to work through this with them and not by just handing out money as that is not a solution because like in any culture you will have bad apples.. and what I mean by this is for example if you put 10 million in my hands Everyone would have a nice car and ski-doo if you gave it to my wife everyone would have homes and creating business with jobs to better self sustain... just handing out money is not the solution and i think that is obvious....
As for Appiwattiskat Debeers should just hand over money not the goverment but again they signed something without understanding what they were signing ..
They have suffered and they will suffer if things don't change .. many other cultures suffer too but not what i am talking about now...
THEY need jobs and educational systems not pre fab trailers called schools and not job on the band members council...
They need help and not in the symbol of $$$$$ They need help homes,school,jobs Not $$$$ Because maybe some of the reserve chiefs are like me and suck ass at spending money ..
01-27-2013 11:42 AM
New school coming 2013 to appawatiskat
01-27-2013 11:48 AM
Canada needs to work with natives to first helping them reserve their land rights they next not giving them money but helping each and every reserve find ways for being self sustainable and producing jobs within the community.
So do you think the Native people should just forget about the agreements and treaties and the money owed them for the continued use of ‘their’ land?
I personally have no problem with First Nations people going into various forms of business and more power to them.
01-27-2013 11:57 AM
Sure, why not.
Go into business, do well, i'm sure a sense of pride would be generated. Win, Win.
Could be tougher on the isolated reserves, but if there is a will.....
Don't know but maybe some isolated reserves have done well.
01-27-2013 12:07 PM
No I don't and in many cases they are getting the fund and they are not I am saying that they need to concentrate on what is important and start with that ... Is money important sure of course it is but is their children being educated and learning what hard work and providing for your family feels like Yes sir...
We all know the goverment is not going to say here is alot of money were also coming to build the schools and give you what you need to create jobs and give you all the land back..
if you and other natives want to fight for it all and get a little bit more then nothing be my quest what I think is they need to concentrate of what there fighting for.. They deserve alot but they owe themselves alot too ...
money from treaties are important but i think they need to concentrate and make a difference instead of saying we want this that and that and that and that and this and basically getting a are you crazy we can't do that response they need to say ok right now our childrens education is important let;s fight for that.. Win that then move on to the next ..
treaties are important but let me ask you this if you looked into the eyes or your 7 year old daughter and she was starving or close too,freezing and could not read the street sign would you say Man I need to take care of those treaties right now ..
There fights need to be with 1 agenda at a time not 5 or 6 .... they keep fighting they will win if they fight right and if Canada's goverment does it right they will they can help them without just forking over millions and see it barely make a difference... Even other natives are saying Chief spnce has alot to answer for and I agree... I mean just because iam the eldest in my family doesn't mean i know how to manage money ...
If you want to take over the world would you try to fight the US,Korea and china all at once or would you go at it one at a time..
It's not hard to know what they are owed now it's time for them to do it right and i refer to both natives and the goverment when i say this ....
Treaties is just a part of what they want to be a big movement but they need to do it one at a time ... ..
01-27-2013 03:00 PM
Is money important sure of course it is but is their children being educated and learning what hard work and providing for your family
It’s not just the ‘money’. There is far more to it than that. It’s about culture and land and heritage. They do not want to become what has happened to people in other countries through the ages who have been absorbed and changed ‘completely’ into another dominating society.
Some reservations the people do live in what we would consider poverty…..and those Natives there probably consider it the same in comparison to the majority of our lives. The thing is it is there decision that their society is more important than themselves. It is not unlike our own when they go off to war to protect their society and people. During the Blitz in England during WW2 thousands of people died. Their homes and buildings were destroyed and their families and even children died. Despite what history has said as it is often written by the victors……many people just wanted to give up. To them half a loaf was better than no loaf at all. To the Germans, well they applauded these people and said it was good that they were thinking of their families and children and Germany guaranteed them a good life…under German rule. The Brits…..decided differently.
When it comes to the First Nations people, each Reservation and each situation has to be looked at based on their own particular situation. I have no idea how much money each Rez gets. A thousand dollars to a Rez in southern Ontario or BC is probably worth 3 or 4 hundred to a Reservation up north. Houses, road repair, schools, meeting halls, etc etc etc are all more costly up north, from the material being used to the distance the material has to travel. I could go on from how the money is distributed to interference on Native land to Corporations that have not lived up to their ends of agreements, to regulations by Indian Affairs that hinder Native people….but it would be too lengthy and like many other facts and proof of the past….would be ignored.
New school coming 2013 to appawatiskat
I believe it has been 5 to 8 years they have been asking for one.
01-27-2013 03:05 PM
I believe it has been 5 to 8 years they have been asking for one
maybe and this is just a thought!
they could have spent some of the money that was given to them for a school rather than buying 5.3 MILLION in stocks and bonds as shown on their finacial statements!
but again thats just an idea
01-27-2013 03:15 PM
01-27-2013 03:42 PM
A school is just another empty building without teachers. Are there qualified teachers living on this reserve? If not, how do they plan on convincing a teacher to live in this squalor? Will they supply a home for these teachers?
01-27-2013 03:54 PM
Yes, a friend of ours has taught on the same reserve for over thirty years. They provide housing & a Northern Allowance along with their own Union Benefits.
Not sure if that is the same across the country.
He has his own home in Winnipeg where he lives during the holidays.
He is Aboriginal with an Education Degree. Their TAs also have an education & certification.