The last two disputes opened on us were from one customer who wanted to return an item after a month of having it and the other had the item for almost two months. We sell used clothing.
I completely understand and agree with the fact that ebay requires us as sellers to have a return policy. We'd have one even if ebay didn't require it, it's just good business. We are also quite flexible and easy with ours...we give extensions at Christmas time and if a buyer contacts us not long after the 7 days we require we don't put up a fight.
But expecting us to accept returns after two months is ridiculous. I don't even think huger retailers would even accept that.
Overall I am happy with the opportunities that ebay has provided our company and in the past I have bit my tongue on the many things they just don't do right. But after 10 years of selling I am a little fed up that they are still doing too many things poorly. It's unacceptable.
If a buyer clicks on a button that means they accept the terms of the deal...we as sellers are held responsible for our end, customers should be as well. If a customer accepts a 7 day return policy, then if they want to return an item upon receipt, then they should respect the terms of the policy and contact for a return within 7 days. How hard would it be for ebay to add the software that a seller adds his tracking to show when an item was received and if the customer files a claim more than 7 days after that, then it is not accepted. Hell give an extra 7 days as a grace period, I'd be fine with that as well. But 30 and 60 days is completely unreasonable.