Hi all,
The concept of the DSR is I believe, at least I hope it is, well intentioned, in that it is an attempt to make improvements to the eBay Market place. But there there are some very serious flaws in it's design that will cause no end of problems for eBay and the rest of us.
The major flaw for me eBay is in a sense disciplining it's children, us, without telling us why we are being spanked, and yet expect improvement. This is what I mean. Since the DSR is anonymous and the seller does not know the buyer or the item in question, the seller does not know the specific issue that needs to be improved. If I have an particular item that I keep getting a low rating on shipping cost I could then to focus my efforts on improving a specific problem. We are going to be rated/disciplined with only a general Idea of why we suck and no access to the tools or information needed to actually improve.
Now to make matters worse, on the other side of the coin, eBay has given up on disciplining the other half of the school all together by not allowing sellers to give feedback. Only allowing positive feedback is as good as giving none at all. We have all seen the children of parents in the parents eyes the child can do no wrong. Dudley from the Harry Potter series comes to mind first.
So this is great. We now have a market place where 1/2 the people are neurotic, stressed out, paranoid work-a-holics trying to get along with unrestrained bullies. At the very least it should be interesting and never dull.
The second major problem is that the DSR system will be too easy to manipulate because it is anonymous. I will let the real smart people on the boards figure all the ways.
And lastly I would like to voice my disappointment to the eBay management in the way they effectively gave us a 1-2% Fee increase while spouting how nice they were to decrease insertion fees.
I really don't think the management has really thought this through. Or maybe there just not smart enough.
Cheers all-
Gehres