Self insurance (cookie jar) RICARMICs statistics to 2017

I'm using this as a distraction to finishing off my year end book keeping....which I hate doing very much....

 

Notes:

-I live in the stamp collectors world, so these results are all from postage stamp selling categories

-I sell only on .COM, I ship worldwide, and I have no blocks on buyers (but I do maintain the blocked buyer list)

-this includes items lost to "crime" as well. "Crime" is defined here as situations where I think people purposefully buy with bad echeques, or claiming lost in transit but that is only from using my spider senses.

-I sell a lot of stuff internationally, over 35% of my packages go outside North America

-the numbers below are specific to eBay sales. As I mentioned in other threads, I experience losses both real and "crime" related via the other online venues I use so package loss rate is not only an ebay buyer issue.

 

It is also worth noting that for 2017 I continued to have 3 types of insurance:

1. Self insurance for the small stuff

2. Canada Post for the first $100 only when items are sent expedited, expresspost, or trackable (I have begun using tracked shipping more frequently moreso because I believe buyers expect it for larger purchases, or when my spider senses are tingling which seems to happen more now!)

3. 3rd party insurer (Hugh Wood) for stuff over $200

(Did not utilize 2 or 3 in 2017 (or 2016 either))

 

2017 results

% of shipments = .0071 = under 3/4 of 1% of packages lost, so about 1 in 140 packages are lost

(all lost packages were  not tracked)

% of sales = .0044 = under 1/2 of one percent loss rate $ wise

13 items "lost"*** in 2017 Australia,Canada(5),Colombia,Italy,Russia(2),USA(3*)

   3 believed to be lost to "crime" (Canada,Russia(2) based on spider senses)

   10 lost and unrecovered(so far). 1 Found later** Canada, 2 arrived later & repaid Colombia, Italy

   3 repaid (Buyer found or advised delivery later and repaid: Canada, Colombia, Italy)

*2 of the USA losses were to USA forwarding companies (1 buyer from Paraguay, 1 buyer from China)
** on return from vacation, lot was lost in a pile of junk mail which was not dealt with and found for a few weeks
*** 1 lost lot to Canada and 1 to Italy were lost to long time, regular buyers who have continued to purchase regularly since AOK.

 

Things I did in 2017.

-nothing new it seems in 2017 different from 2016

 

2016 results

% of shipments = .004 = under one half of 1% of packages are lost, so about 1 in 250 packages are lost

% of sales = .0024 = about one quarter of 1 percent loss rate

   8 "lost" in 2016 USA(2),Canada,India,Oman,Russia,Australia,Bolivia

   1 believed to be lost to "crime" (based on spider senses)

   7 lost and unrecovered(so far). 1 USA advised arrival later and repaid

   1 repaid (Buyer advised delivery later and repaid: USA)

   1 odd situation, other USA buyer convinced me to unblock them and they successfully purchased 3 more items

 

Things I did in 2016.

-I China & Brazil require trackable shipping, ie lowest shipping $17.50 regardless item size. Number of buyers especially China increased over the year, they began buying batches of stuff to make the postage palatable.

-decided against adding extra custom shipping costs to Russian buyers (not tracking) so far, am also considering doing the same for others

-I sell in US$ so the lower $C rate gives me more room to make packages trackable, which I’ve been doing more to new buyers and/or buyers in scary countries

-I did change my flat rate shipping to Standard Shipping (outside the US) to add a few more days to the est delivery date

 

 2015 results

% of shipments = .0097 = about 1% of packages are lost, so about 1 in 100 packages are lost

% of sales = .0090 = about 1 percent loss rate

   13 "lost" in 2015 Russia(5) Belarus, Canada, China, French Polynesia, Kuwait, Pakistan, South Africa, Sri Lanka

   3 believed to be lost to "crime" (Russia, ordered 3 separately close together)

   9 lost and unrecovered(so far)

   1 repaid (Buyer advised delivery later and repaid: Canada)

 

Things I did in 2015.

-I changed China and Brazil to custom shipping requiring trackable shipping, ie lowest shipping $17.50 regardless item size. Number of buyers dropped dramatically.

-am considering adding extra custom shipping costs to Russian buyers (not tracking), however had many sales, including one for $1500 which more than offsets the minor losses.

-I sell in US$ so the lower $C rate gives me more room to make packages trackable, which I’ve been doing more to new buyers and/or buyers in scary countries

 

2014 results

 % of shipments = .0051 = 1/2 a % of packages are lost, so about  1 in 200 packages are lost

 % of sales = .0040 = .4% of sales ie less than 1/2 of one percent loss rate

     10 "lost" in 2014 USA(2) Nepal(1) China(2) Brazil(3) Germany(1) Russia (1)

       2 believed to be lost to "crime" (China)

       5 lost and unrecovered(so far) USA(2) Brazil (2) Russia 

       3 repaid (Buyer advised delivery later and repaid: Nepal,Germany,Brazil)

 

2013 results one half of one percent of sales loss rate:

0.51% "insurance" loss rate (10 unrecovered losses USAx3,Argentina,Chinax3,France,Israel,North Korea)

   0.3% as a result of "crime" (6 shipments)

   0.21% as a result of items lost in the mail (4 shipments)

(Note in 2013 2 packages “lost” and later arrived and Buyers repaid(Brazil, Russia), 1 package loss partially covered by Canada post, no losses covered by 3rd party insurer)

 

2012 results - under 1% of sales loss rate:

0.83% "insurance": loss rate (unrecovered loss 9 shipments Argentina,Australia,Brazil,Canada,Chinax2,Indonesia,Russia,Turkey)

   0.78% as a result of "crime" (2 shipments)

   0.04% as a result of items lost in the mail (7 shipments)

A reminder that 2012 is the year that CP covered the small packets, I had a few recoveries this way. 

I had a big crime loss within Canada (this was also spelled out in a different thread).

Message 1 of 23
latest reply
22 REPLIES 22

Re: Self insurance (cookie jar) RICARMICs statistics to 2017

Hey Momc, I was already on board (see "I'm in agreement with Momc")!

I have actually lost tracked packages, although the last time was probably 3 years ago so loss rate for them is very rare.

I've been evolving my "tracking" thoughts to be more customer expectations centric than "profits for ricarmic" centric. Statistically it never makes sense to pay for insurance if you sell enough stuff, however customers seem to be getting used to being able to watch their items en-route and I think they are expecting it more now than they did a few years ago. This, along with the "reward" my customers get of nice current stamps on the boxes has been encouraging me to send stuff tracked that I would not otherwise.

I also have the pleasure of shipping some large $$$ items each year that would worry me if I didn't have insurance, and the insurance add on to cover them that I have is very economical (it is less than the cost to insure just one of those packages if I used CP's insurance) which also happens to cover everything else, and I'm happy to have something that reduces one of the many worries we sellers have these days!

Message 21 of 23
latest reply

Re: Self insurance (cookie jar) RICARMICs statistics to 2017

Oh, I know, I wasn't trying to disagree with you at all. I just worried that my 'who needs third-party insurance when you have tracking' argument was coming across as too forceful for the OP. Myself, I use tracking on everything bigger than an envelope or worth more than $60 CAD just because it settles my nerves and also because toy buyers sort of seem to expect it. Like, the demographic of people who are buying toys for their children don't understand that parcels can also be sent without tracking and are immediately suspicious. And collectors paying for stuff want to know where their item is along the way. It just works better for me, although it has stemmed my flow of small orders to Europe somewhat. 

Message 22 of 23
latest reply

Re: Self insurance (cookie jar) RICARMICs statistics to 2017

Myself, I use tracking on everything bigger than an envelope

 

And of course, if it doesn't fit in an envelope, it goes parcel service, and those are usually tracked anyway.

 

or worth more than $60 CAD just because it settles my nerves

 

This is why I often suggest Signature Confirmation to newbies with high value sales.

For a buck fifty, she can relax.

 

and also because toy buyers sort of seem to expect it.

I seriously think half the concerns of buyers comes from following a tracked parcel as it move through hub and spoke delivery systems to their doorstep.

The other half of the concerns comes from buyers whose purchases were sent without tracking.

Message 23 of 23
latest reply